Discernment Counselling

Should We Stay Together? Discernment Counselling Explained

Sometimes the question isn’t how to fix a relationship. It’s whether to keep trying at all.

Often, partners don’t feel the same way. One may be ready to work hard on the relationship while the other is quietly wondering whether it’s over. Standard couples therapy can stall in that situation, because it assumes both people want to make it work.

Discernment counselling was designed for exactly this point. This article explains what it is, how it works, and who it suits.

What discernment counselling is

Discernment counselling is a short, structured approach for couples where one partner is leaning out of the relationship and the other is leaning in. It was developed by US family therapist Dr William Doherty, who calls these “mixed-agenda” couples.

Its goal is clarity, not repair. Rather than trying to solve the relationship’s problems, it helps both partners understand what’s happened and decide, with more confidence, what to do next.

Discernment counsellingCouples therapy
Main questionShould we try to fix this?How do we fix this?
Who it suitsPartners who feel differently about stayingPartners who both want to work on the relationship
LengthUsually 1 to 5 sessionsOften several months
FocusUnderstanding and decidingChanging patterns together
OutcomeA clear decision about the next stepImprovement in the relationship

How discernment counselling works

Discernment counselling is usually between one and five sessions. Sessions tend to be longer than standard therapy, often 90 minutes to two hours.

Each session follows a similar shape:

  1. A short joint conversation with both partners and the counsellor.
  2. Separate conversations with each partner. This is where most of the work happens. The leaning-out partner can explore their doubts honestly, and the leaning-in partner can look at their own part in the relationship’s difficulties.
  3. A joint wrap-up, where each partner shares what they’ve learned and you plan the next step.

The three paths

By the end, couples are working towards one of three directions:

  • Keep things as they are. Take a break from deciding, without major changes for now.
  • Separate. Move towards ending the relationship, ideally with more clarity and less conflict.
  • Commit to couples therapy. Put separation off the table for a set period, often around six months, and work on the relationship together. Then reassess.

There’s no right answer. A good discernment process supports either decision. Research with people who went on to divorce found they valued the honesty and structure, and reported more cooperative co-parenting afterwards.

Who it suits, and when it doesn’t

Discernment counselling can help when:

  • One partner is unsure about staying, and the other wants to keep trying
  • You’ve tried couples therapy before and it didn’t move things forward
  • Separation has been raised, but no firm decision has been made
  • You want to make a big decision carefully, especially if you share children

It isn’t the right fit in every situation. It’s generally not recommended where there is family or domestic violence, where one partner has already firmly decided to leave, or where someone is attending under pressure. Serious mental health or substance use concerns that need immediate care should come first [2].

In those situations, individual support is usually the safer and more helpful starting point.

Deciding about your relationship

At Evallies, couples therapy isn’t only for couples who are sure they want to stay together. Our couples therapists also help partners work out whether to stay, and how to separate well if that’s the decision.

The focus is on the healthiest outcome for both of you, not on keeping you together at any cost. Our therapists stay neutral and focus on the patterns between you rather than deciding who’s to blame. If you decide to keep working on the relationship, they use evidence-based approaches such as emotionally focused therapy and the Gottman approach.

A decision like this can also take a toll on each partner individually. Our psychologists can offer separate support, for example with anxiety, grief or burnout. Because we work as one team, that support can be coordinated with your couples work.

Practical details

In person or by video. Sessions are available at our Malvern East and Kew rooms, or by secure video across Victoria. With video, you can join from the same place or from two separate locations.

Cost and Medicare. Couples sessions generally aren’t covered by Medicare, because rebates under a Mental Health Treatment Plan are for individual treatment. Some private health extras policies contribute, so it’s worth checking your cover. Our reception team can talk you through fees, and the FAQs answer other common questions.

Getting started. If you’re not sure where your relationship is heading and want to talk it through, get in touch when you’re ready, or start with our new patient form.

If you’re experiencing family or domestic violence, contact 1800RESPECT on 1800 737 732, or call 000 in an emergency.

References

  1. Cook E. Discernment counseling for couples on the brink of divorce. GoodTherapy; 2017.
  2. GoodTherapy. Discernment counseling.
  3. Emerson AJ, Harris SM, Ahmed FA. The impact of discernment counseling on individuals who decide to divorce: experiences of post-divorce communication and coparenting. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy. 2021;47(1):36-51.

This article is for general information only and isn’t a diagnosis or a substitute for personalised medical advice. If you have concerns about your health or wellbeing, please speak with your GP or a qualified health professional. In an emergency, call 000.

Ready to Take the First Step?

If you are looking for considered, coordinated mental health care either for yourself, your child, or someone you support, you are welcome to get in touch, or to browse the practitioner profiles to see who might be the right fit. Evallies is here when you’re ready to begin.